A District Court judge in Montana often presides over child custody issues, and in doing so, decides the custody fate of minor children. In Montana, MCA Section 40-4-228 is controlling law and it says that a Judge can make custody decisions without a parent’s fitness hearing. Is that fair, and should a Montana District judge follow Montana Code when deciding custody matters?
The U.S. Supreme Court in Troxel v. Granville, 530 US. 57 (2000), and Stanley v. Illinois 405 U.S. 645, 658 (1972), made it clear that “all parents are constitutionally entitled to a hearing on their fitness before their children are removed from their custody”. Troxel and Stanley are unambiguous. In Troxel, the U.S. Supreme Court said That Washington’s Grandparent Visitation Statute was unconstitutional.
Writing for the majority, Justice Sandra Day O’Connor wrote that “the liberty interest at issue in this case – -the interest of parents in the care, custody, and control of their children – – is perhaps the oldest of the fundamental liberty interests recognized by this Court”.
How do these cited rulings affect Montana Statute MCA Section 40-4-228? MCA 40-4-228 (5) that says “It is not necessary for the court to find a natural parent unfit before awarding a parental interest to a third party”.
According to Montana Supreme Court Records an Emergency Request for Relief, Cause No OP 25-0170, filed 03-03-25 involving Judge Amy Eddy, deals with the award of custody of two minor children without a formal parental fitness review and alleges that it denied the biological parents Due Process Rights under the Fourteenth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution.
If the alleged facts in the Montana custody case as presented in the ERR referenced above were included in an action to declare the MCA Section 40-4-288 unconstitutional how would Judge Amy Eddy, if she was elected to the Montana Supreme Court react?
I prefer not to find out, how about you?
Knowledge of the Law, both State, Federal, and the U.S. Constitution are vital in the election of Montana’s Supreme Court Justices and in my opinion Judge Amy Eddy doesn’t have it.


Interesting Fact:
Sandra Day O’Connor, the first woman to serve on the U.S. Supreme Court, spent much of her childhood school year living with her grandmother in El Paso because her parents’ cattle ranch was too remote for regular schooling.
Her parents entrusted substantial day-to-day care to a grandparent without giving up their role as her parents.
It is a simple historical reminder: parents sometimes rely heavily on relatives because they believe it is best for their child. Delegating care is not the same thing as surrendering parenthood.
— Montana Families for 40-4-228 Reform
Thank you for sharing! So glad to see this.
Interesting Fact:
Sandra Day O’Connor, the first woman to serve on the U.S. Supreme Court, spent much of her childhood school year living with her grandmother in El Paso because her parents’ cattle ranch was too remote for regular schooling.
Her parents entrusted substantial day-to-day care to a grandparent without giving up their role as her parents.
It is a simple historical reminder: parents sometimes rely heavily on relatives because they believe it is best for their child. Delegating care is not the same thing as surrendering parenthood.
— Montana Families for 40-4-228 Reform
Thank you so much for the information. We as people of the state of mantana need to know all we can about who we are voting to put in any position in our government. I feel that the child welfare system is very off on rights of parents. I have seen first hand how bad it can get. Our rights under montana state and our united states government should be held in accordance to any other laws that are practiced on a daily basis.
Eddy uses 40-4-228 to create what she calls another parent with the same rights as a natural parent. She gives the third-party medical decision-making while denying parents requests for medical review and allows third-party parents to provide false information about the children to medical providers.
She also acknowledged frustration of contact with the entire biological family and does nothing to correct it.
I have seen Amy Eddy in action. She uses unsubstantiated allegations that are disputed by the evidence and facts of the case as well as speculation and hearsay in her findings of facts. She rules against the Constitutional rights of fit parents.
I hope that voters acquired some insight as to how unfit judge Amy Eddy is to serve on the Montana Supreme Court. I believe she does not review precedent and lacks empathy for parental rights as granted by the 14th Amendment of the U.S Constitution. Please Vote go Dan Wilson.